Liberal and Conservative governments that planted seeds of Islamophobia must now sow the tragic consequences

It is now more than two weeks week since Justin Trudeau and Erin O'Toole put out statements and made speeches condemning the hate-motivated attack which killed four members of the Afzaal Family, and injured nine-year-old Fayez Afzaal in London, Ont. Since the attack against this Muslim family, few have mentioned that Trudeau’s and O’Toole’s parties in previous governments planted the seeds of Islamophobia in Canada in the years after 9/11 through their anti-terrorism policies, which portrayed Canadian Muslims as a threat to the country. Those seeds have produced bumper crops of anti-Muslim hate in the ensuing years, and the blood of the Afzaal family, as well as the Muslims killed in a Quebec City mosque in January 2017, stains the foundations of the Liberal and Conservative parties, the men who led them, and Members of Parliament who were part of those governments. The hate-motivated murder of the Afzaal family is rooted in the post-9/11 world, a place where anti-terrorism laws were adopted that violated Charter rights, where the Muslim community was suspected of harbouring terrorists, and where political rhetoric and anti-Muslim prejudice became a part of the fabric of Canadian society. The man who allegedly attacked the Afzaals grew up in that environment, exposed to Islamophobic political and media messaging, which contributed to his actions on June 6. In the years following the 9/11 attacks, Canada put in place flawed anti-terrorism laws adopted because of paranoia and fear. To maintain peace with the Americans, the governments of Jean Chrétien, Paul Martin, and Stephen Harper took their lead from the U.S. and implemented anti-terrorism laws that mimicked American ones. Harper, as opposition leader and as prime minister, carries considerable responsibility for inflaming Islamophobia in Canada. In opposition during the 2000s Harper took every opportunity to use the threat of “Islamist terrorism” to score political points, including by vilifying Maher Arar, Abdullah Almalki, Muayyed Nureddin, and Ahmad El Maati, Muslim Canadians who were imprisoned and tortured in Syria and Egypt on flimsy or faulty evidence, with the complicity of Canadian officials. Harper was also responsible for leaving Canadian child soldier Omar Khadr in America’s illegal Guantanamo Bay prison, where he was tortured, again with Canadian complicity. His government ignored UN recommendations to return Khadr to Canada where he would get a fair trial. Harper's security agenda seemed to consist of implementing policies that cast suspicion on Canadian Muslims and their faith, and their loyalty to Canada. His refusal to settle the human rights violation cases involving Almalki, Nureddin and El Maati, his refusal to repatriate Khadr, his implementing the Bill C-51 security legislation, the “Barbaric Cultural Practices” snitch line, his government's attempt to violate the rights of Zunera Ishaq, a Muslim woman who wanted to wear a niqab face covering during her citizenship ceremony, all fed the Islamophobic attitudes in Canada, which created the conditions for the attacks in London, and the one in Quebec City in 2017. Media also played a role in boosting anti-Muslim narratives by giving politicians platforms to spin Islamophobic talking points, and by covering terrorist threats through an Islamophobic lens. The small fire that had been steadily fed by both Liberal and Conservative governments since 2001 exploded into an inferno when Donald Trump appeared on the political scene in the U.S. and began vilifying Muslims. The combination created a recipe for a Muslim tragedy, and resulted in the Quebec City mosque shooting in 2017, the murder of a Muslim volunteer at a mosque in Toronto, and what happened in London this month. Other factors that have contributed to Islamophobia in Canada include Quebec’s Bill 21, the “secularism” law that was founded on anti-Muslim sentiment; the refusal of governments to implement and lead a national anti-hate strategy, despite repeated pleas from activists; the failure to aggressively tackle the explosion in white supremacy; and conservative political leaders tolerating and shielding those in their parties who advocated Islamophobic messages online or in public statements. Both the Liberals and Conservatives have much to atone for. They not only sowed the seeds of Islamophobia, but also fed its growth through their policies, political rhetoric, and apathy in dealing with the anti-Muslim hate their policies birthed. The Liberals and Conservatives want to be seen as the defenders and protectors of Muslims right now after the attack in London. But the policies their governments created, and their narratives that fed anti-Muslim prejudices, were major factors that ultimately led to the terrorist attack against the Afzaal family. Canadians need to remember that when Trudeau and O’Toole talk about fighting Islamophobia, and confront them on this when they ask for your vote come election time. Fareed Khan is the founder of Canadians United Against Hate and a Muslim community activist. The Hill Times

Liberal and Conservative governments that planted seeds of Islamophobia must now sow the tragic consequences

The blood of the Afzaal family, as well as the Muslims killed in Quebec City in 2017, stains the foundations of the Liberal and Conservative parties, the men who led them, and the MPs who were part of those governments.

How can Ontario achieve net zero, with greater energy reliability and resilience? Roadmap to a clean energy future

It’s time to unleash Canada’s energy advantage

Language matters: measuring what you are versus what you are not

The Federal Court decision to overturn the single-use plastic ban is a step backwards for the planet—and our health

Is it better to talk about unity and not practise it, or not talk about it at all?

Poilievre’s miscues won’t save Trudeau

Québec City mosque attack anniversary a time for action against Islamophobia

Canada’s foreign policy is at odds with Trudeau’s promise to fight Islamophobia

Calls to combat Islamophobia prominent in record-setting June for federal advocacy

A solemn reminder of a need for action

Remembering the Québec City mosque attack and taking action against Islamophobia

News

Get free news updates

Opinion

Submit a guest opinion article

resources

Advertise

subscribe

get help

Liberal and Conservative governments that planted seeds of Islamophobia must now sow the tragic consequences

The blood of the Afzaal family, as well as the Muslims killed in Quebec City in 2017, stains the foundations of the Liberal and Conservative parties, the men who led them, and the MPs who were part of those governments.

Get The Weekend Point of View Newsletter