Home Page News Opinion Foreign Policy Politics Policy Legislation Lobbying Hill Life & People Hill Climbers Heard On The Hill Calendar Archives Classifieds
Hill Times Events Inside Ottawa Directory Hill Times Store Hill Times Careers The Wire Report The Lobby Monitor Parliament Now
Subscribe Reuse & Permissions Advertising FAQ
Contact UsLog In
Opinion

Caddell misleadingly compares situation in Israel to hypothetical one: Heap

Re: “Israel, with all its flaws, deserves Canada’s support,” (The Hill Times, April 21). The recently published opinion piece by Andrew Caddell contains a number of flagrant misrepresentations. Mr. Caddell quotes a parodic video published by Independent Jewish Voices Canada as saying something it did not. His purported quote is demonstrably false, and misconstrues both the words and the clear intent of the video. As anyone with a reading knowledge of French who consults the video in question can easily verify, it in fact says something quite different, i.e., that this relation is “based on the instrumentalization of the Jewish community in Canada,” (“basée sur l’instrumentalisation de la communauté juive au Canada.”)
Mr. Caddell’s misrepresentations go beyond a sloppy rendition of the French subtitles. He also misleadingly compares the situation of Israel to a hypothetical one where “if nuclear weapons in upstate New York were aimed at Canada,” when in fact, exactly the opposite comparison would be accurate. The only military power in the Middle East capable of threatening its neighbours with nuclear weapons is Israel, a longstanding hold-out non-signatory of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (a fact that a former employee of Global Affairs Canada can reasonably be expected to know, even if The Hill Times doesn’t check).
Readers understand that “opinion” pieces are not held to the same standards of fact checking as journalistic reporting, but writers like Mr. Caddell should not be enabled to publish patently false claims in support of their opinions.
David Heap
Associate professor
University of Western Ontario

London, Ont. 

Related Stories

Politics This Morning

Get the latest news from The Hill Times

Politics This Morning


Your email has been added. An email has been sent to your address, please click the link inside of it to confirm your subscription.

Budget investments not enough to replace need for new round of COVID student benefits, says Green leader Paul

News|By Alice Chen
Liberal MP Julie Dzerowicz says the market has recovered enough to replace the benefit with actual employment, but students advocates say the jobs aren't there yet.

Planned U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan leaves questions over Canada’s ability to provide international assistance

News|By Neil Moss
The security situation in Afghanistan 'will have the effect of us having to reassess all our programming in Afghanistan,' says Chris Kilford, who served as deputy military attaché in Kabul.

U.S.-backed vaccine waiver should force Canada to support initiative, say politicos

News|By Neil Moss
Pressure is mounting on the Canadian government to back the waiver as it has received support from the U.S. and more than 30 Liberal MPs are calling on Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to champion the initiative.

Feds’ appointee to address military sexual misconduct aims to have mandate approval at ‘end of May’

News|By Beatrice Paez
The lieutenant-general says one of her first assignments is to ‘issue guidance’ for military leaders ‘in the next few weeks’ on how to lead with inclusivity in mind.

Rollout of infrastructure money ‘lagging indicator’ of effort to spur economic activity, says deputy minister

News|By Palak Mangat
A ‘real impetus’ in earmarking funds for infrastructure projects is getting it approved, says one bureaucrat, but one MP adds there may still be gaps in how Ottawa allocates such dollars.

Senate, House report at least 30 COVID-19 cases in Parliamentary Precinct since pandemic’s early days

On April 29, PSPC launched a rapid testing program after a 10-case outbreak among Centre Block construction workers, the most reported cases among workers on the Hill, according to new data.

‘You are walking on eggshells’: infectious disease docs say ‘trust in vaccines is fragile,’ NACI guidance unhelpful

News|By Mike Lapointe
The federal government has been urging Canadians to get the first vaccine available.

Bill C-10: how closing the YouTube ‘loophole’ created a political firestorm

The partisan finger-pointing that has defined the debate around Bill C-10 over the past two weeks is rooted in an attempt by the government, and a few MPs, to make sure that influential streaming companies that rely on uploaded content, such as YouTube, are bound by rules designed to promote Canadian cultural content, and protect Canadian broadcasters. 

Bill to entrench new Senate leaders for good has arrived

Bill S-4 would give better pay and official status to the leaders of the new groups in the Senate.
Your group subscription includes premium access to Politics This Morning briefing.