Home Page News Opinion Foreign Policy Politics Policy Legislation Lobbying Hill Life & People Hill Climbers Heard On The Hill Calendar Archives Classifieds
Hill Times Events Inside Ottawa Directory Hill Times Books Hill Times Careers The Wire Report The Lobby Monitor Parliament Now
Subscribe Free Trial Reuse & Permissions Advertising
Log In

Michaëlle Jean’s chances ‘very slim’ to keep Francophonie seat: observers

By Samantha Wright Allen      

The Liberal government is offering 'lukewarm' support at best for the Haitian-Canadian ex-governor general, say Francophonie watchers.

Canada's former governor general Michaëlle Jean is vying for a second term leading the International Organisation of La Francophonie, but will face stiff competition from a France-backed Rwandan candidate when a decision is made at the Oct. 11-12 Francophonie leaders' summit in Armenia. The Hill Times file photograph
Share a story
The story link will be added automatically.

Michaëlle Jean’s chances at a second term leading the International Organisation of La Francophonie have disappeared or are “very, very slim,” say observers, amid fallout from spending controversies that have shaken support for her even in Canada, her home country.

Winning support in the closed-door and consensus-based vote during the Francophonie leaders’ summit Oct. 11 to 12 in Armenia was already an uphill battle. Ms. Jean is up against a Rwandan candidate backed by France, a powerful member of the OIF. The Haitian-Canadian is also perceived to have a lack of influence among African nations, which represent the largest voting bloc of the 84 member states and governments in the OIF.

“Her problem with spending has coloured her bid,” said Jocelyn Coulon, a former policy adviser to Stéphane Dion when he was foreign affairs minister, but “the geopolitics [of] France in Africa has taken over this.

“France wants to expand and consolidate its presence in Africa,” and as the biggest funder of the OIF, that has sway. Also potentially affecting the vote is the desire among African countries to see one of their own lead an international organization, he said, noting Ms. Jean’s opposition has the backing of heavyweights like Morocco, Senegal, Côte d’Ivoire, the Democratic Republic of Congo, and Egypt.

“It says a lot about the loss of influence of Canada in Africa,” he added, noting Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s (Papineau, Que.) only trip was back in 2016.

Justin Massie, a professor of political science at the Université du Québec à Montréal, echoed that assessment, saying Ms. Jean’s “reputation is not good.”

“That’s just perhaps the excuse for France withdrawing its support [of] Michaëlle Jean,” he said. But, more importantly, France has always used the organization “as instrument for its foreign policy orientation in general,” using it “as a force multiplier in Africa.”

“It’s more about consensus-building,” and in that context especially given Ms. Jean’s mixed approval in Canada, her chances are “very, very slim, to say the least.”

Rwandan Foreign Minister Louise Mushikiwabo’s bid, even with French President Emmanuel Macron’s influence, isn’t a sure thing, said former diplomat Ferry de Kerckhove. France’s late support upset some African nations as “a kind of colonial imposition,” as did Rwandan President Paul Kagame’s announcement of her bid, without discussion, at the end of an African Union meeting he chaired, said Mr. de Kerckhove.

“This is unheard of,” and an “anti-African practice,” said Mr. de Kerckhove, who served as then-prime minister Stephen Harper’s sherpa at the Francophonie from 2006 to 2008. He also pointed to Rwanda’s troubled past and its decision a decade ago to prioritize English as an official language as points against assured ascension.

That’s still not enough to shake the desire for an African candidate over the Haitian-born Canadian, said Mr. Coulon.

In private circles, some are discussing an agreement to split the four-year secretary-general term into two, Mr. de Kerckhove said, though Mr. Coulon hadn’t heard that as an option in his discussions, while Prof. Massie suggested it’s unlikely, and a “no-go” for many countries.

“I would like her to have four years, but I think they’ll split two-two,” said Mr. de Kerckhove, who considers Ms. Jean a friend but agrees she’s had some failings and a bit of a “queen-like attitude” that didn’t go over well among members.

“The intentions are there, but it’s a lot of fluff. And she thinks she has the means for her action, when in fact she’s got a tiny budget,” he said of the former governor general, “so she replaced action with speeches, and that’s where the disconnect between reality and desire appears so glaringly.”

But, he said media coverage has been “overdone” on the issue of Ms. Jean’s alleged excess. Her lack of influence has more to do with her natural disadvantage as an outsider, without the same connection and access to African heads of state her predecessors had.

In the spring, Canada’s French media reported extensively on the controversy surrounding her post, uncovering questionable spending, like the use of $500,000 to renovate her official residence in Paris, and $20,000 to buy a piano. There was also the four-day stay at the Waldorf Astoria for $50,000, a youth project that cost $1-million and was way over budget, and the charge her husband had a chauffeur and car paid for, though he has no official OIF role.

Mélanie Joly took over the Francophonie file after a July cabinet shuffle. The Hill Times photograph by Andrew Meade

Without addressing specific reports, Ms. Jean said this constituted a “smear” campaign with “scurrilous and specious accusations,” in June 5 Globe and Mail op-ed where she reaffirmed her commitment to lead the organization and defended her record. 

Regarding the renovations, she said both Canadian and OIF officials said upgrades were needed to make the residence habitable, and that the work was regularly inspected by the Canadian Embassy in France, which owns the apartment.

She also said “the OIF has implemented rigorous transparency mechanisms validated by an internal audit process, external auditors, and the Finance and Administrative Commission as part of regular accountability reports to its member states and governments.”

Canada’s position hasn’t changed, and the federal government supports Ms. Jean’s continued mandate, said Jeremy Ghio, a spokesperson for La Francophonie Minister Mélanie Joly.

“Our government values international organizations and we believe it is important for Canada to have Canadians in leadership roles in such organizations which promote our values, including within the OIF,” he said by email in response to questions. “On transparency, we have been very clear: we expect that organizations receiving funding from the Government of Canada use it with the utmost care and transparency,”

Better defining La Francophonie’s “core mandate,” and improving its functioning and transparency were listed as priorities in the August mandate letter to Ms. Joly (Ahuntsic-Cartierville, Que.) when she took over the file from International Development Minister Marie-Claude Bibeau (Compton-Stanstead, Que.).

That represented a demotion of the file to a junior minister, said Mr. Coulon and Prof. Massie, who both questioned the ferocity of Canada’s campaign on Ms. Jean’s behalf. The way the Liberals pushed her bid “was lukewarm at best, and with caveats [suggesting] that they’re not…[going] to war to defend her,” said Prof. Massie, while Mr. Coulon described it as “very discreet.” Mr. Ghio said he couldn’t comment on what Canada is doing to campaign. Mr. Trudeau is expected to travel to Armenia for the Francophonie summit and a bilateral visit from Oct. 11 to 13. Canada is the organization’s second-biggest donor. 

In June and July, before a major African Union summit, Mr. Trudeau made a number of calls to African leaders with a stake in the OIF,  including Madagascar, Côte d’Ivoire, Benin, Cameroon, Niger, and Senegal.

Rwandan President Paul Kagame and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau took part in a youth event at United Nations General Assembly last week. Both countries have a candidate up to lead La Francophonie. Photograph courtesy of the United Nations

Opposition parties decline to endorse Jean, call for transparency

The Conservatives “can’t endorse” Ms. Jean’s candidacy as they still “haven’t got answers,” said the party’s Francophonie critic Steven Blaney (Bellechasse-Les Etchemins-Lévis, Que.)

“We have to put the interest of Canadians first instead of blindly supporting someone because it’s someone from Canada,” said Mr. Blaney, noting that Canada, under the Liberals, has yet to be accountable for “legitimate questions” and must do so to maintain the credibility of the organization.

Conservative Francophonie critic Steven Blaney says the party can’t endorse Michaëlle Jean because it hasn’t received enough answers about ‘legitimate questions’ about her leadership. The Hill Times photograph by Andrew Meade

Back in May, when France came out for Rwanda, colleague Gérard Deltell (Louis-Saint-Laurent, Que.) called her “an embarrassment to Canada.”

Before Monday’s election, Quebec’s potential premiers were lukewarm in their support, reported the Canadian Press. The province’s new leader, Coalition Avenir Quebec’s François Legault was the least supportive, declining to endorse her and saying he would “reserve his decision” until later, creating the potential for a divided Canadian delegation, which includes national representatives as well as for Quebec and New Brunswick.

Bloc Québécois spokesman Antoni Gilbert said none of the party’s MPs were available for an interview Friday or Monday and said comment by email wasn’t possible. In May, Bloc MP Monique Pauzé (Repentigny, Que.) (who at the time was sitting outside the Bloc caucus with several other former Bloc MPs) spoke dismissively of Ms. Jean’s lifestyle, said that the OIF is “sinking into insignificance,” and asked when the government would withdraw its support for her.

NDP MP Robert Aubin said Ms. Jean “faces an uphill battle,” especially given the “general consensus” that an African candidate should lead OIF.

He didn’t offer clear support for her. 

“It is obvious that we would like to show solidarity toward a Quebecer and a Canadian on the international stage, but Michaëlle Jean will have to explain and demonstrate what steps she will take in the future to restore the public’s confidence,” said Mr. Aubin (Trois-Rivières, Que.) by email.


The Hill Times

Politics This Morning

Get the latest news from The Hill Times

Politics This Morning

Your email has been added. An email has been sent to your address, please click the link inside of it to confirm your subscription.
More in News

All eyes on Red Chamber, as Senators push back on key government bills

Senators have proposed dozens of changes to the Liberals' impact assessment and gun bills, have concerns about its solitary confinement legislation, and recommended its tanker-ban bill not proceed.

House may need to sit in summer to pass new NAFTA deal, says Trade Committee chair

News|By Neil Moss
‘I've never seen that before, but it's doable,’ says Liberal MP Mark Eyking. But MPs still say the Americans should make the first move toward ratification.

Senate on a spending ‘slippery slope,’ says Sen. Marshall, as Senators review office-expense rules

Senators rejected staff-suggested changes to the rules governing how they spend money from their office budgets, in favour of examining the rules and coming up with their own changes.

Lobbying czar has ‘concerns’ for her office’s budget, warns court decision could widen workload

The office’s work has ‘evolved in complexity, litigiousness, and level of scrutiny,’ says Nancy Bélanger.

Conservatives say they’re ‘confident’ Mark Norman will expose more Liberal wrongdoing

Peter MacKay says if Vice-Admiral Mark Norman speaks out about his ordeal, 'I don’t think it will mean good things for the Liberal government.'

Senate compromise on government’s signature impact assessment bill would put maligned regulators back in charge on environmental review panels

Plus, a ban on importing shark fins is now steps away from law.

‘They should be nervous’: Liberals now focusing ‘completely’ on election readiness in regional, national caucus meetings

News|By Abbas Rana
The Liberals will be under attack from all sides in the next election campaign, but Liberals say they have a good story to tell and some say they need to sharpen up their communications strategy before it's too late.

Ford’s cuts in social programs could be opening for federal Liberals to campaign against federal Conservatives in October, say Liberal MPs

News|By Abbas Rana
Conservative MP David Tilson says it’s too early to jump to any conclusion about the impact of the Ford government’s policies on the next federal election outcome.

Remains of old barracks, guardhouse focus of ‘significant’ archaeological dig on Parliament Hill

MPs learned about the archaeological finds through a briefing from officials at the House Affairs Committee last week, during which new details about proposed work plans for Centre Block were shared.
Your group subscription includes premium access to Politics This Morning briefing.