Home Page Election 2019 News Opinion Foreign Policy Politics Policy Legislation Lobbying Hill Life & People Hill Climbers Heard On The Hill Calendar Archives Classifieds
Hill Times Events Inside Ottawa Directory Hill Times Store Hill Times Careers The Wire Report The Lobby Monitor Parliament Now
Subscribe Free Trial Reuse & Permissions Advertising FAQ
Log In

Refugee advocates dispute Canada facing ‘crisis’ over arrival of claimants from U.S. border, NDP says ‘Conservatives misrepresent issue’

By Beatrice Paez, Jolson Lim      

Politicians and some journalists have been loose with the words 'illegal' and 'crisis,' which doesn't apply to Canada's situation, says Alex Neve of Amnesty International Canada.

Conservative MP Michelle Rempel, pictured July 16 with caucus colleagues Pierre Paul-Hus, left, and Larry Maguire, right, considers the issue to be a crisis in part because many of the refugee claimants will soon face 'eviction' in August since they’ve been temporarily housed in two college dormitories in Toronto, which are vacant during the summer. The Hill Times photograph by Andrew Meade
Share a story
The story link will be added automatically.

Debate over Ottawa’s handling of the settlement of refugee claimants has both the Trudeau government and the Conservatives trying to bait each other into appearing too soft or too hard on the hot-button issue, but the Tories should be wary of appealing to the baser instincts of voters, say advocates and political players.

“I think the opposition has to be fairly responsible here, too. You can get into the mechanics of the problem and the downloading issues, which are all legitimate issues. You’ve got to be careful not to get into baiting on identity issues, because there are some Canadians who may have a less generous view of immigration,” said Tim Powers, vice-chairman of Summa Strategies and a former adviser to Conservative leaders. “And they want to be careful of playing to some of the lower-based needs of those people.”

If the Conservatives want their message to cut through the noise, then they should stick to the systemic issues around it, he added.

Conservatives, led by Conservative MP Michelle Rempel (Calgary Nose Hill, Alta.), the party’s immigration critic, have been applying pressure on the federal government to divulge more details on its plan for dealing with migrants coming in from the United States border. Ms. Rempel has often invoked the need for a “compassionate asylum system,” saying that it’s not “fair” for claimants to be housed in makeshift arrangements because the system is too overloaded to accommodate them. Her party has called for the government to designate the entire Canada-U.S. border a “port of entry,” which critics have said is impractical and would only push refugees to take more dangerous routes.

At the same time, Ms. Rempel and others in the party have been called out for using language that critics say play to some Canadians’ fears about refugees. The party has been using the issue as a hook to draw more supporters through a petition titled “Illegal Border Crossers,” in which it says the number of crossings will continue to climb “upwards of 400 individuals per day.”

But the latest government figures show there’s been a decline in the number of irregular border crossers who have sought asylum, with 1,263 recorded in June. It’s the lowest number recorded since June 2017. Whereas the average number of claims in April was 83, it’s since gone down from 57 claims per day in May to 39 claims per day in June. Many of the refugee claimants over the past year have come from Haiti and Nigeria.

‘Absolute precision is absurd’

Refugee advocates say that refugee numbers typically ebb and flow and it’s hard to predict when the numbers will rise.

While it’s “legitimate” for parties to press the government for more transparency, it shouldn’t be out of a sense of crisis, says Alex Neve, secretary general of Amnesty International Canada.

“I find it very deeply troubling and objectionable that so many politicians and, quite frankly, a number of journalists, have been very loose with the words ‘crisis’ and ‘illegal,’ neither of which apply here,” Mr. Neve said. “It does build a sense of recklessness in the public if all you hear is ‘crisis,’ ‘illegal.'”

Janet Dench, executive director at the Canadian Council for Refugees, agreed: “There’s isn’t a crisis. There is and has always been ups and downs in the number of refugee claimants that come to Canada.”

Mr. Neve said the government should design systems flexible enough to respond to pressures, but that the “notion we can somehow … predict [flows] with absolute clarity and be able to manage it with absolute precision is absurd.”

The Conservatives tweeted and then deleted this image this week, which linked to a petition saying that the Trudeau government is to blame for a crisis at the border. Screen capture of Conservative Party’s July 16 tweet

The narrative around refugee claimants has also become a “bit one-sided,” Ms. Dench said. She questioned the conversations around the “cost” of resettling refugee claimants, saying that there are many communities that need people to fill labour shortages.

“When you hear provinces saying ‘We don’t want to contribute anything towards the costs,’ I might ask, ‘Are those provinces also saying any of the benefits that come from refugee claimants, they also want to be excluded from that as well?’”

The Conservatives’ “illegal border crossers” petition comes with a promo tweet, which went out on July 16, but was deleted either late at night that day or sometime on July 17, that references a Financial Post op-ed that says Ottawa is on the hook for a crisis it created because of a tweet Prime Minister Justin Trudeau sent in January 2017, in which he said: “To those fleeing persecution, terror & war, Canadians will welcome you, regardless of your faith. Diversity is our strength .”

In response to questions on why the tweet was first posted and then taken down, party spokesperson Cory Hann said by email that “the situation at our border is not about any one group of people,” it’s “a policy failure of the Trudeau government.” The image of the back of a man carrying luggage was from an Associated Press photo, and Mr. Hann said it was used by multiple mainstream outlets such as CBC.

In an appearance on CTV Power Play earlier this year, Conservative House leader Candice Bergen (Portage-Lisgar, Man.) also said that “asylum seekers” crossing the border are “jumping the queue,” ahead of refugees who “are trying to come into Canada legitimately.”

Mr. Neve disputed the notion that there’s a “queue for making a refugee claim.”

“International law recognizes that when people are on the move, seeking safety, they are lawfully entitled to cross borders and seek protection. They don’t have to wait to see whether they fit into a particular quota or category for a particular year,” he said.

Ms. Rempel has also raised questions about whether the acceptance of irregular border crossers has diverted resources from those trying to come to Canada “legally.” She considers the issue to be a crisis in part because many of the refugee claimants will soon face “eviction” in August since they’ve been temporarily housed in two college dormitories in Toronto.

The number of RCMP interceptions along the Canada-U.S. border has dropped in the past few months. Source: Immigration, Refugees, and Citizenship Canada

In response to the Ontario government withdrawing its co-operation for resettling claimants, Ottawa announced on July 16 that $11-million of the $50-million that had been earmarked to help provinces and cities cope with the “influx” will be directly given to the City of Toronto.

Under the Progressive Conservative government of Premier Doug Ford, Ontario has demanded that Ottawa bear the costs associated with helping refugee claimants get settled while they await a decision on their claims. Before the election, Kathleen Wynne’s Liberal government was exploring the idea of setting up an information-sharing system to identify where the pressures in the system are for things such as housing.

“We were fully expecting it to be launched some months ago,” said Ms. Dench, adding that it’s unfair to blame Ottawa when it was looking to co-operate with Ontario.

‘Concentrated effort of misinformation’

Much of that debate around the language used to describe the issue was on display at a House Immigration Committee meeting on July 16, held because of a Conservative motion calling for a study examining the impact irregular border crossings have had on communities.

NDP MP and committee vice-chair Jenny Kwan (Vancouver East, B.C.) told the committee that the use of the word “illegal” to describe the migrants had bothered her “for some time.” She cited the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, which states that anyone who enters the country and claims refugee protection can’t be charged with any offences under immigration law and some Criminal Code sections pending their claims.

NDP MP Jenny Kwan says the Conservatives have been ‘misrepresenting the issue’ of refugees coming into Canada from the U.S. border. The Hill Times photograph by Andrew Meade

Liberal MP and committee member Gary Anandasangaree (Scarborough-Rouge Park, Ont.) said there’s been a “concentrated effort of misinformation” and criticized the Conservatives for saying that 400 people cross the border every day, something he said was rebuffed by recent figures.

Ms. Rempel, in reply, cited the words of the immigration minister himself. In March, Mr. Hussen told the committee that he has used both “illegal and “irregular,” saying “I think both are accurate.”

Conservative MP David Tilson (Dufferin-Caledon, Ont.) said there was a sign at Roxham Road, a main crossing point in Quebec, stating that crossing the border was, in fact, illegal.

Ms. Kwan noted that she’s called on Mr. Hussen to use the “correct” terminology both at committee and in Question Period. She also took aim at the Conservatives, saying they conflate the stream of border-crossing inland refugees with streams for government-assisted and family-sponsored refugees, and general immigration.

“The Conservatives have continually misrepresented the issue,” she told reporters after the meeting. “Nobody is queue jumping, nobody is taking a spot away from someone else.”

Nelson Wiseman, a University of Toronto professor, said the appeal of the Conservatives’ tougher stance on who enters Canada plays to “not just their base.” He said polling numbers during the Syrian refugee crisis found more Canadians supported the Conservatives’ stance than popular support for the party.

The difference then, however, was how political commentators skewed towards the Liberals’ effort to resettle 50,000 refugees and a fewer and disproportionate number of opinions opposing it were found, he said.

“A lot of people are uncomfortable about it now. It’s not politically correct for newspapers to represent that. People like Ford, like Rempel know that.”

“It’s smart for them to do it,” Prof. Wiseman said of the Conservatives’ approach to refugees. “I’m not saying I would do it … but it’s more than their base. They recognize that more than 30 per cent of the public supports this position.”



The Hill Times

RCMP interceptions along the Canada-U.S. border, last 12 months

  • June 2018: 1,263
  • May 2018: 1,869
  • April 2018: 2,560
  • March 2018: 1,970
  • February 2018: 1,565
  • January 2018: 1,517
  • December 2017: 1,978
  • November 2017: 1,623
  • October 2017: 1,890
  • September 2017: 1,881
  • August 2017: 5,712
  • July 2017: 3,134
  • Total: 26,962

— Immigration, Refugees, and Citizenship Canada

Explore, analyze, understand
Inside 2020 Books – Inside Ottawa and Inside Canada
Get both Inside Canada pocket books for a special price.

Get the book
Spinning History: A Witness to Harper’s Canada and 21st Century choices
An unvarnished look at the Harper years and what lies ahead for Canadians

Get the book
2018 Guide to Lobbyist Gifting Rules
The 2018 Guide to Lobbyist Gifting Rules is the essential resource for your work on federal issues.

Get the book
Related Policy Briefings
Privacy and Security in the Digital Age
Short and informative analyses on policy challenges that bring background and recommendations to policymakers, journalists and the general public.

Read policy briefing

Politics This Morning

Get the latest news from The Hill Times

Politics This Morning

Your email has been added. An email has been sent to your address, please click the link inside of it to confirm your subscription.

Liberal MP Lamoureux continues prolific speaking record, raising opposition ire

‘I’m living the dream,’ says Liberal MP Kevin Lamoureux of his regular House of Commons presence. With more than 550 House interventions so far this Parliament, he’s second only to the Speaker.

‘It’s an ongoing battle’: Bob Rae’s push to move the needle on human rights at the UN

News|By Neil Moss
'You don't stop trying to find ways of resolving differences in opinion, but I do think in this day and age you need a whole range of ways of expressing concern and trying to move opinion,' says Bob Rae.

In parliamentary ‘game of chicken,’ NDP side with Liberals to defeat Conservative motion, averting snap election

News|By Beatrice Paez
The nail-biter 146-180 vote came down in large part to the NDP. Its 24 representatives voted alongside the Liberals and the Greens’ three-member caucus in defeating a Conservative motion.

Feds misled House Defence Committee in 2019 on status of peacekeeping pledges

News|By Neil Moss
'It's a bald-faced lie if they actually said they did and didn't,' says Conservative Defence Committee vice-chair James Bezan of the non-registration of the promised 200-member Quick Reaction Force.

Infrastructure bank’s $10-billion growth plan raises hope of green bond push in Canada

Green bonds are fixed-income financial instruments usually used to secure funding for sustainable infrastructure projects.

Violence directed at Indigenous fishers in Nova Scotia leaves ‘black eye’ on Canada, says Mi’kmaq Senator, as he and rookie Mi’kmaq Grit MP urge long-term solution

News|By Palak Mangat
'I think the current route is a dead end, so if they continue to bang their heads against a wall, everyone’s going to get a headache,' says Independent Nova Scotia Senator Dan Christmas.

House vote looms over Conservative motion that could trigger federal election, as Liberals double down

News|By Palak Mangat
Government House Leader Pablo Rodriguez dodged questions if the government was responsible for setting the stage for a stand-off that could trigger an election, saying the question should be asked of the Conservatives.

‘Six systemic crises’ confronting Canada, and politicians, policy-makers, health-care professionals need ‘systems thinking’ to tackle them, says public policy expert

News|By Mike Lapointe
Global Brief magazine editor Irvin Studin says politicians and policy-makers' thinking is 'too small, it’s too linear, it’s too path dependent, and it looks increasingly absurd as these systemic crises.'

Canada needs a new ‘fiscal anchor’ and Freeland needs to share financial plans, says PBO Giroux

Parliamentary Budget Officer Yves Giroux says he's found it 'much more difficult to get information out of the minister’s officer' since Parliament returned with Chrystia Freeland in charge of the nation's finances.
Your group subscription includes premium access to Politics This Morning briefing.