Home Page Election 2019 News Opinion Foreign Policy Politics Policy Legislation Lobbying Hill Life & People Hill Climbers Heard On The Hill Calendar Archives Classifieds
Hill Times Events Inside Ottawa Directory Hill Times Store Hill Times Careers The Wire Report The Lobby Monitor Parliament Now
Subscribe Free Trial Reuse & Permissions Advertising FAQ
Log In

Rookie opposition MP’s bill could pass the Liberal-majority House

By Marco Vigliotti      

Marilyn Gladu credits her extensive outreach and collegial, collaborative tone for pushing her bill forward in the House, where it has won support from her Conservative colleagues, NDP and Liberal MPs.

First-term MP Marilyn Gladu's private member's bill establishing a national palliative care framework looks set to pass with broad support in the House of Commons, a rare feat for any bill, let alone seldom-passed private member's legislation. The Hill Times photograph by Jake Wright
Share a story
The story link will be added automatically.

Conservative MP Marilyn Gladu knew the odds were stacked against her.

It’s rare, she was told, for any private member’s bill to win approval, let alone one proposed by a rookie opposition MP in a majority Parliament.

But she also saw an opportunity.

Following the contentious debate over medically-assisted dying, Ms. Gladu (Sarnia-Lambton, Ont.) proposed a private member’s bill, C-277, establishing a national framework for palliative care in Canada. It’s now set to go for third reading in the House of Commons on May 8 after winning support from the governing Liberals, NDP MPs, and Ms. Gladu’s colleagues in the Conservative caucus, extremely rare for any piece of legislation, let alone an opposition private member’s bill.

Ms. Gladu said she owes it all to hard work and a co-operative spirit.

“You come and you’re not adversarial, you want to hear people’s input, you’re open to working collaboratively to amend the bill if needed, and you go from there,” she said, in an interview, of how the bill has managed to work its way through Parliament.

The bill calls for the development of a national framework that would provide Canadians with access to palliative care in hospitals, at home, at long-term care facilities, and at residential hospices.

Existing services, Ms. Gladu said, vary among jurisdictions, with 70 per cent of Canadians currently lacking access to palliative care.

It’s a number that shocked her, considering the wealth of palliative care services offered in her southwestern Ontario riding.

Between its hospice and hospital, Sarnia is home to 20 palliative beds, five palliative care specialists, and an integrated network of home care, she said, noting there are only 200 palliative care specialists and 30 hospices in all of Canada. 

“Honestly, I thought it was like that everywhere,” she said, calling on Ottawa to use funds from its planned infrastructure spending package to build more hospices, specialized facilities providing end-of-life care that are more comparable to communal homes than hospitals.

The cost of hosting a patient at a hospice, she noted, totals, on average, $200 to $300 per day, compared to $1,200 at a hospital.

If passed, the legislation would give Ottawa one year to come to terms with the provinces on training and education on palliative care for health-care providers, supports for palliative caregivers, and to ensure consistent access to palliative care across the country, among other initiatives.

In drafting the bill, Ms. Gladu said she deliberately sought to win broad support from the major parties in the House, and said she believed the NDP would be in favour of substantive legislation on palliative care after MP and party leadership candidate Charlie Angus (Timmins-James Bay, Ont.) shepherded through a motion on the issue in 2011.

From there, Ms. Gladu said she reached out to the diverse contingent of players in the palliative care space, such as physicians, nurses, hospice operators, home-care providers, and occupational therapists, to “find out what should be in the bill.”

What she heard was clear and resounding: the government needs to clearly lay out what services it plans on funding. 

“Right now there’s partial funding in some places for palliative care, and zero funding in other places,” she explained.

“So if they decide, for example, all pain control, spiritual counselling, crisis intervention, home care would be covered, that would be a huge difference from what happens today.”

Noah Shack, director of policy for the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs, the advocacy group for Canada’s Jewish federations, praised Ms. Gladu for reaching across the aisle and for working collaboratively with palliative care proponents while drafting her bill.

CIJA is part of an inter-faith coalition that has called for better access to palliative care services, which include religious counselling.

“Ms. Gladu’s success can be attributed to her hard work, and her ability to collaborate with colleagues from all parties who understand the growing importance of the issue,” Mr. Shack told The Hill Times via email.

Although private members’ bills rarely pass, Ms. Gladu’s legislation was able to win broad support because all parties in the House understood that palliative care is a “non-partisan issue” that is “extremely important and deeply personal to many Canadians,” said Mr. Shack.

Ms. Gladu said she had to be careful in crafting her bill to ensure her legislation reflected what the provinces were responsible for, and where the “federal government can lead.”

After the bill was drafted, she said it was reviewed by a number of people, then shunted off to Health Minister Jane Philpott (Markham-Stouffville, Ont.) and her staff. 

After being introduced in the House, the bill made it through to the committee stage, where several amendments were added. Most notably, language was altered to make it clear the federal government was playing a supporting role but the provinces would be responsible for actually implementing the measures, as well as restoring the position of the commissioner of palliative care.

Members also wanted to take out the language in the framework related to how the government would implement it, there being several mechanisms at the government’s disposal to implement the measures contained in the legislation, including the Canada Health Act.

When reached for comment, Minister Philpott’s office said the Liberals were in favour of the bill in its current iteration.

“The government supports MP Gladu’s Bill C-277, as amended at committee, and looks forward to the report stage and third reading of the bill,” Andrew MacKendrick, the minister’s press secretary, said in a statement.

“All signals are that it should receive approval at third reading. That said, we take nothing for granted until it does,” Ms. Gladu said.

If the bill passes third reading, it will need to win approval in the fragmented Senate. The Conservatives currently hold the most seats, with 39, while the Independent Senators Group holds 35, the Liberals 18, and other independents seven.

Conservative Senator Yonah Martin (British Columbia) has offered to sponsor the bill when it comes to the Senate, and Ms. Gladu said she’s already been talking to other Senators to explain the legislation in hopes they too will support it.

Although the fragmented nature of the Senate might complicate matters, if the bill receives all-party support in the House, it would send a “very strong message” to the Upper Chamber, said Ms. Gladu. 

Ms. Gladu also pointed to the amendments put forward by Senators to the assisted dying legislation as an indication there’s an “appetite” in the Upper Chamber for her bill.


The Hill Times 

Politics This Morning

Get the latest news from The Hill Times

Politics This Morning

Your email has been added. An email has been sent to your address, please click the link inside of it to confirm your subscription.

Throne Speech’s climate promises draws mixed reviews, with NDP saying it’s a rehash of old pledges

The Throne Speech promised action on climate change like the country has never seen before, but some experts and politicians are skeptical the Liberal government can deliver.

Former PM Turner was a ‘living legend,’ ‘a great defender of Parliament,’ say politicos

News|By Palak Mangat 3:55 PM ET
While the conditions for Liberal longevity might not have been ripe, Liberal strategist Charles Bird says late former prime minister John Turner came to the leadership when 'he was already something of a living legend.'

Foreign policy focus in new session should be on China, U.S., and human rights, say Parliamentarians

News|By Neil Moss
'The No. 1 [foreign policy] priority is our relationship with the United States,' says Independent Senator Peter Boehm as the U.S. presidential election quickly approaches.

Political parties reach last-minute deal to temporarily change House rules for hybrid Commons, electronic voting

The rule changes includes a sunset clause, with the terms expiring Dec. 11.

‘Whatever it takes’: Trudeau says austerity not an option in the face of staggering job losses, health crisis 

News|By Beatrice Paez
The speech did not promise a full-fledged budget, but said an update to the feds’ COVID-19 Economic Response plan would be coming this fall.

‘I wrote this memoir from the heart’: former Supreme Court chief justice wins Shaughnessy Cohen Prize for memoir, Truth Be Told, a ‘unique and tantalizing glimpse’ into top court  

News|By Palak Mangat
'Writing this book has brought me close to Canadians and the wonder of our national diversity. This prize is the icing on the amazing cake that has been my life': former Supreme Court chief justice Beverley McLachlin.

Presidential election could change course on unilateral tariff use, but Canada-U.S. trade tensions will remain: experts

News|By Neil Moss
If Joe Biden wins the U.S. presidency, he will be constrained in the use of unilateral tariffs, say experts, while Donald Trump's re-election may leave Canada once again targeted by national security tariffs.

COVID-19 containment, economic recovery expected to drive fall lobbying

Lobbyists will also be keeping an eye on progress on the government's backlog of big-ticket legislation and regulatory reforms this session.

Parties close to agreement on voting plan, Parliament return, but committees prove sticking point, says Bloc MP

The Standing Orders have to be amended to allow MPs to vote remotely, and according to Bloc deputy House leader Christine Normandin, there’s agreement among parties for those changes to be made temporary.
Your group subscription includes premium access to Politics This Morning briefing.