Home Page Election 2019 News Opinion Foreign Policy Politics Policy Legislation Lobbying Hill Life & People Hill Climbers Heard On The Hill Calendar Archives Classifieds
Hill Times Events Inside Ottawa Directory Hill Times Store Hill Times Careers The Wire Report The Lobby Monitor Parliament Now
Subscribe Free Trial Reuse & Permissions Advertising
Log In
Opinion

The good and bad of family dynasties in politics

By Tim Powers      

Ches Crosbie, son of former federal cabinet heavyweight John Crosbie, is testing the waters of a Newfoundland PC leadership bid.

Ches Crosbie, top left, and, counterclockwise from bottom left, his father and former cabinet minister John Crosbie, pictured in 1983; Toronto city councillor Mike Layton; his father, former NDP leader and Toronto city councillor Jack Layton; former NDP MP Bill Blaikie; and his daughter, former NDP president Rebecca Blaikie. The Hill Times photographs by Jake Wright, and courtesy of chescrosbie.ca and Alasdair Roberts
Share a story
The story link will be added automatically.

OTTAWA—While elements of the American and British electorate seem repulsed by elites in politics and empowered by their rejection the Canadian environment is still different. If anything, political dynasties remain very much alive in Canada.

A second Trudeau is our prime minister and another man named LeBlanc is a senior minister in his government. We have had two Ghizs serve as premiers of Prince Edward Island. We have had members of the Blaikie family play prominent roles in the NDP. Laytons and Fords have dominated city councils in Toronto. And now in Newfoundland and Labrador we have another Crosbie seeking a top political job.

America eventually tired of this, having had enough of Bushs and Clintons. Will Canada eventually suffer from the same fatigue? Ches Crosbie, son of former federal cabinet heavyweight John Crosbie, will soon find out. Crosbie, the younger, has announced his intention to begin an initial pursuit of the leadership of the Progressive Conservative Party of Newfoundland and Labrador. He hasn’t formally declared as he is on a “listening tour,” but he will all but certainly be in.

Full disclosure here: Ches is a cousin of mine and I worked for his father. But I have no role in Ches’ campaign and wish him well. Though, like any good family, we will likely agree to disagree on a few things.

What is fascinating to me about Ches’ initial campaign roll-out is how in some ways he is going against the prevailing wind of political success. He is playing up family and family history. While it is true you can’t run from it, and he most certainly has much to be proud of, hoping to push the message of continuing the “family business” of politics has not gone over well in other jurisdictions recently. You get labelled as entitlement-minded, and that can be a political killer. Ask the Clintons.

While the dynamics of my own province are different, the world of politics and its influences is smaller. Ches and his team are making a calculated gamble that being a Crosbie in Newfoundland and Labrador brings more political credibility than baggage. While his father John was a much beloved and a historic figure who helped modernize the province, he has not held an elected office for 24 years. Times have changed in that span. Yet Ches Crosbie boldly promotes on his website that “Ches learned much about politics from his parents, Hon. John and Jane Crosbie.”

Justin Trudeau most certainly didn’t run away from the fact that he was Pierre’s son; he tactically embraced it from time to time. What he did do, though, was bring in his own team of advisers. Ches Crosbie, on the other hand, seems to be taking a different approach. He has a few members of his father’s team around and a lot of family. While they are all good people, a very different dynamic can play out. That may be the only place where the Crosbies and Trumps align.

Ches Crosbie has lots of success in his own right. He was a top litigator working on many class-action suits for diverse groups in need. He has done much philanthropic work at home. His greatest political asset is that Stephen Harper rejected him as a candidate for the federal Conservatives in 2015. Newfoundlanders and Labradorians by and large still haven’t found a fondness for the former prime minister. Ches Crosbie is most certainly his own person, but he seems more inclined to transact politics from the dynasty perspective.

This is the first test of political romanticism and the relevancy of the political establishment in Canada since the U.S. election. It will be interesting to watch. Never mind how I now have just changed the dynamic of family dinners.

Tim Powers is vice-chairman of Summa Strategies and managing director of Abacus Data. He is a former adviser to Conservative political leaders.

The Hill Times

Politics This Morning

Get the latest news from The Hill Times

Politics This Morning


Your email has been added. An email has been sent to your address, please click the link inside of it to confirm your subscription.

Platform costing measure gets nod, but fixes for getting info needed, says PBO

News|By Palak Mangat
'Different leadership could have decided that ‘no, we won’t collaborate with you, because we don’t have to under the legislation,’ says Parliamentary Budget Officer Yves Giroux. 'We want legislation to be clarified.'

Rookie MPs get crash course on life in ‘Ottawa bubble’

News|By Beatrice Paez
Learn to reach across party lines for relationships and resist sticking to talking points, new MPs told at a Carleton University-hosted orientation event.

Iranian investigator into downed Flight 752 should be replaced due to past, says former Liberal justice minister

News|By Neil Moss
Iran's chief justice Ebrahim Raisi was part of a 'death commission' in 1988, during a period of political repression which saw thousands of dissidents executed.

Lingering Phoenix issues ‘no surprise’ to union leaders, as annual survey shows increase in pay problems

News|By Mike Lapointe
The 2019 federal budget allocated $523.3-million over five years, starting in 2019–20, to 'ensure that adequate resources are dedicated to addressing pay issues,' according to PSPC.

Senate should be ‘very careful’ of widespread rule changes and ‘unintended consequences,’ says retiring Sen. Day

From a boyhood dream of holding the country’s top political office to almost 20 years in the Red Chamber, retiring Sen. Joseph Day reflects on his parliamentary career.

Agriculture Minister Bibeau was the most-lobbied MP in 2019

In an election year, lobbying activity dropped by 30 per cent compared to 2018.

No more shush deals: Senators ready to press for accountability, harassment reforms once Parliament returns

A Senate subcommittee approved a new policy for dealing with harassment in the Red Chamber before Christmas.

‘There’s a risk of excessive polarization of the party’: Harper’s interference in Conservative leadership dividing Conservatives

News|By Abbas Rana
Some Conservatives say Stephen Harper is certainly entitled to his opinion, but others say he should stay out of this critical leadership race.

Reboot of Trudeau ‘from sunny to serious’ a recognition Canadians want a serious prime minister, say politicos

News|By Abbas Rana
‘It's almost like we're seeing a new prime minister,’ says Jennifer Stewart, CEO Of Syntax Strategies.
Your group subscription includes premium access to Politics This Morning briefing.