Home Page News Opinion Foreign Policy Politics Policy Legislation Lobbying Hill Life & People Hill Climbers Heard On The Hill Calendar Archives Classifieds
Hill Times Events Inside Ottawa Directory Hill Times Books Hill Times Careers The Wire Report The Lobby Monitor Parliament Now
Subscribe Free Trial Reuse & Permissions Advertising
Log In
Global

Canada shaped China’s new domestic abuse law: feds

By Peter Mazereeuw      

Domestic violence had become a politically 'safe' human rights issue for other countries to discuss with China’s government, which knew it had to make progress on the issue, says Canada's ex-ambassador.

Chinese Premier Li Keqiang visited Ottawa in September. Under Mr. Li, China sent a delegation to Canada in 2014 to learn how Canada's legal system handled domestic abuse. The Hill Times photograph by Jake Wright
Share a story
The story link will be added automatically.

Canada’s federal government helped to guide China through the drafting of its first national domestic abuse law passed late last year, even fielding a visit from top Chinese lawmakers working on the project.

Chinese officials “turned to Canada for inspiration” in the early stages of drafting the legislation, which explicitly outlaws physical and psychological abuse in domestic relationships for the first time in that country, according to Global Affairs Canada.

The Canadian foreign ministry even boasted that it “was able to influence” the drafting of the landmark legislation in its annual performance report for last year. The federal Justice and Public Health departments and local government agencies hosted visiting Chinese officials working on the legislation.

Passed in December 2015, China’s law “prohibits any form of domestic violence,” formally defines domestic violence, and streamlines the process for obtaining restraining orders, according to Chinese state news agency Xinhua. The law covers married and unmarried opposite-sex couples who live together, and children in foster care. It covers both psychological and physical abuse, but does not apply to same-sex couples.

A delegation of senior Chinese officials visited Canada in October 2014 to meet with Canadian counterparts in the Justice, Status of Women, and Public Health departments and “learn from Canadian experiences in combating domestic violence,” according to Global Affairs Canada.

Canada also provided input into the first two drafts of the Chinese law passed last December, according to the Canadian foreign ministry, which called it an “important milestone” despite “certain shortcomings.”

“Canada’s efforts … have to an extent helped shape the final text of the law,” said foreign ministry spokesperson Kristine Racicot in an emailed response to questions.

Chinese officials were interested in some of the definitions around abuse used in Canadian law, which behaviours are subject to criminal punishment, and when mediation should be used, said Guy Saint-Jacques, who served as Canada’s ambassador to China from October 2012 to October 2016.

Domestic violence had become a politically “safe” human rights issue for other countries to discuss with China’s government, which knew it had to make progress on the issue, said Mr. Saint-Jacques.

At the time of the Chinese delegation’s visit, former Conservative MP John Baird was serving as Canada’s foreign minister, and former Conservative MP Peter MacKay was serving as the country’s justice minister. Neither responded immediately to requests to be interviewed.

Under former Conservative MP and foreign minister John Baird, Canada’s foreign affairs department helped Chinese officials to shape the early drafts of what became their first major domestic abuse legislation, passed in December 2015. Photograph by Jolanda Flubacher courtesy of the World Economic Forum

CIDA laid the groundwork

“It’s a good example of reaping the fruits of long-term collaboration,” said Mr. Saint-Jacques in an interview.

The now-defunct Canadian International Development Agency helped to build ties between the two countries on the issue of domestic violence for years, funnelling $5-million between 1998 and 2005 towards a project with the All-China Women’s Federation, a quasi-governmental Chinese agency, to help increase co-operation between the women’s federation, police, and Chinese courts in dealing with domestic violence, according to Global Affairs Canada and Mr. Saint-Jacques.

Chinese officials approached Mr. Saint-Jacques early in the process of drafting the law to ask that he facilitate a visit of Chinese lawmakers to Canada, he said. Canada agreed, and the Chinese officials ultimately came to examine how Canadian government, judicial, and social service agencies handled domestic abuse cases, he said.

The Canadian embassy’s efforts were bolstered by Maureen McTeer, a Canadian lawyer and the wife of former prime minister Joe Clark, who participated in a series of events focused on women’s rights at the Canadian Embassy in China in 2015. The events were held to mark the 20th anniversary of the UN Fourth World Conference of Women, held in Beijing in 1995.

Routine to consult other countries: embassy

Domestic abuse has long been an issue kept hidden in Chinese society, but that is beginning to change. In 2011, Kim Lee, the American wife of Chinese celebrity entrepreneur Li Yang, sparked controversy in China by publishing a photo of a swollen head wound she said she had received from her husband, and was ignored by Chinese police. Mr. Li later admitted to the China Daily that he hit his wife, but said he didn’t think she would reveal it to the public since it’s “not Chinese tradition to expose family conflicts to outsiders.”

About one-quarter of married Chinese women experience domestic violence at some point, but few report it to authorities, says a press release from the Chinese government.

Chinese officials were willing to discuss the issue with Canada’s government thanks to their past co-operation, said Mr. Saint-Jacques, and would later say Canadian laws and practices around domestic violence served as the “inspiration” for the Chinese law.

The Chinese Embassy in Canada said it was a “long-standing practice” for China to learn, for reference, from the “good legislative experience” of other countries.

Canada and China have “sound exchanges” in the justice field, said a statement from Yang Yundong, a diplomat and spokesperson for the embassy.

Spousal violence occurred in about four per cent of Canadian couples between 2009 and 2014, down from about seven per cent from the decade prior, according to Statistics Canada.

Same-sex violence left out

Canada’s criminal code does not explicitly identify domestic abuse as a crime, but Canadian authorities can use a variety of offences within the code to prosecute various types of abuse, according to the federal Justice Department.

However, while Canadian laws against violence and harassment apply equally, in principle, regardless of sexual orientation, China’s law does not cover same-sex couples.

Guo Linmao, a Chinese government official, told Reuters that the law did not cover same-sex couples, since the government had “not yet discovered” a problem of violence between same-sex couples.

Same-sex relationships are not commonly discussed in Chinese society, said Mr. Saint-Jacques, and China’s government may have not been ready to publicly acknowledge those relations in its law.

peter@hilltimes.com

@PJMazereeuw

More in News

Trudeau to meet with Black youth who experienced alleged racial profiling on the Hill

In an apology offered in the Chamber on Feb. 19, House Speaker Geoff Regan said, ‘All who come here must know unequivocally that they will be welcomed with equality, dignity and respect.’

‘Underdog’ NDP in Outremont faces ‘hard battle’ to keep ex-leader’s seat: NDP analysts

NDP candidate Julia Sánchez says she has a good campaign team in Montreal, and isn’t losing out on party resources focused on leader Jagmeet Singh's byelection race in B.C.

Federal Court of Appeal sides with BOIE against NDP in satellite-office battle

NDP MPs had been ordered to repay roughly $4-million by the Board of Internal Economy, which they've already started repaying though they've been fighting it in court for five years.

Butts’ exit could help government wield more effective defence strategy in SNC-Lavalin affair, politicos say

News|By Beatrice Paez
Gerald Butts has removed himself from the daily political grind of strategizing how to keep the Liberals in power. But observers say it's unlikely he will be consigned to watch the campaign unfold from the sidelines.

Hill reporters push back against lack of access to MPs in West Block

‘For a reporter, this is terrible,' says CBC's Julie Van Dusen. Two suggestions for new scrum spots were rejected, but talks to find a solution continue.

Perception a problem with retired Supreme Court justices involved in the ‘highly partisan’ SNC-Lavalin affair, say some court watchers

Jody Wilson-Raybould’s hiring of Thomas Cromwell as counsel is ‘good for the client, good for the PMO, good for Canada,’ says a Supreme Court specialist.

Nearly two-thirds of public servants have unresolved pay issues three years after Phoenix launched, survey shows

Results from the 2018 Public Service Employee Survey also indicate harassment stats in the public service are relatively flat despite a PCO push for change.

Criminal charges raises spectre of SNC-Lavalin takeover, but feds’ $180-billion infrastructure plan can find other builders, experts say

News|By Jolson Lim
SNC-Lavalin risks a takeover if it's convicted. But aside from likely outrage in Quebec, Ottawa can find other builders for its infrastructure plans if the company is banned from bidding on federal contracts, experts say

SNC-Lavalin lobbied Liberal-tied ambassador on corruption case, sought help from ex-aides to Chrétien, Mulroney

The Quebec company had extensive access to government ministers and top staffers, and was the only organization registered to lobby for allowing deferred prosecution agreements for white collar crimes.
Your group subscription includes premium access to Politics This Morning briefing.