Home Page Election 2019 News Opinion Foreign Policy Politics Policy Legislation Lobbying Hill Life & People Hill Climbers Heard On The Hill Calendar Archives Classifieds
Hill Times Events Inside Ottawa Directory Hill Times Store Hill Times Careers The Wire Report The Lobby Monitor Parliament Now
Subscribe Free Trial Reuse & Permissions Advertising
Log In
Global

To boost middle class, we need better knowledge and ideas today

By David Crane      

Can the Liberals really deliver on their promise for a strong middle class? If the real test of a strengthened middle class is an increase in the median inflation-adjusted hourly earnings of Canadian workers, then there are reasons to have doubts.

Finance Minister Bill Morneau has failed to provide a serious analytical framework for addressing the middle-class challenge, writes David Crane. The Hill Times photograph by Andrew Meade
Share a story
The story link will be added automatically.

TORONTO—The Liberals won the federal election just over a year ago, running on a platform entitled “A New Platform for a Strong Middle Class.” This is the core pledge made to Canadians by Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and the Liberal government.

But can the Liberals really deliver? If the real test of a strengthened middle class is an increase in the median inflation-adjusted hourly earnings of Canadian workers, then there are reasons to have doubts.

They need much stronger economic growth and a higher rate of productivity growth. But they need more than that. They also need to ensure that the benefits of productivity growth are shared with the middle class. A new study by economists at the Centre for the Study of Living Standards in Ottawa shows that from 1976 to 2014 the middle class has not shared in the growth in productivity in Canada—that the traditional link between rising productivity and a prospering middle class has been broken. Can the Liberals restore it?

The three economists—James Uguccioni, Andrew Sharpe and Alexander Murray—find that between 1976 and 2014, while productivity increased by 1.12 per cent a year, median (middle class) real hourly earnings rose just 0.09 per cent a year. In fact, median or middle class annual earnings, after adjusting for inflation, were $30,167 in 2014, compared to $31,700 in 1976. Both the stagnation in the median hourly wage and the fall in hours worked explain the dismal result for the middle class.

“This disconnect between rising labour productivity and stagnant earnings for the median worker likely explain the prevailing sense of middle-class malaise,” they say. They blame globalization, technological change and institutional change as key factors in the “hollowing out of the middle” in the earnings distribution, all factors that helped elected Donald Trump in the U.S.

As the paper notes, labour productivity is still generating earnings growth for workers overall. “But that earnings growth is benefitting workers at the top and at the bottom of the earnings distribution while the median worker—the representative of the ‘middle class’—has benefitted hardly at all.” Several factors explain why the middle class has fared so badly.

The first, the paper says, is globalization, which includes free trade agreements. “The world’s increased openness to international flows of goods and capital has created opportunities for capital in advanced countries to seek high returns around the world and, at the same time, has brought workers in these economies into competition with the workers of relatively low-wage countries,” it says. If a company can make something for less by offshoring in another country it usually will. Hence, the impact of trade with low-wage countries on jobs and wages “may be larger and more persistent than economists once thought,” the authors of the report concede.

A second factor, the paper continues, is technological change. While technology typically raises the wages of high-skilled workers and lowers the wages of lower-skilled workers, it now appears that computer technology is “increasingly able to automate the kinds of routine tasks once performed by middle-wage workers in clerical or middle-management occupations” as well as continuing to eliminate jobs in manufacturing. In other words, “the middle of the wage distribution is ‘hollowed out.’” Business is heavily focused on replacing humans with technology wherever it can.

But there are other factors as well, as the paper points out. One is that middle-class earnings have not kept up with rising prices. Rising household debt is one response. At the same time, labour’s share of national output is declining while that of capital has been growing; labour’s share of total income fell from 59.9 per cent in 1976 to 53.3 per cent in 2014. If labour’s share had remained unchanged, there would have been an additional $130.8-billion that would have gone to labour rather than capital in 2014.

Not only has the economy become more capital intensive, but much of that capital is being used to eliminate jobs. “Technological developments of recent decades are entirely different from the technological developments which relied on workers in the past,” the paper argues. “Specifically, investment in information and communications technologies in the last two decades has boosted productivity across the board, but has also led to the automation of repetitive jobs.” Labour is becoming a less important part of the production process. The continued weakening of union membership has likewise reduced the bargaining power of the middle class.

As the forces of globalization and technological change continue to play out, the paper warns, highly skilled workers, such as those who can design new computer software, will enjoy high earnings growth while their increased demand for services may lead to some higher-wage growth in low-wage occupations. “But in the middle, earnings do not grow.”

The report concludes with a serious warning: “The forces that are likely causing the stagnation of middle-class earnings are unlikely to disappear in the near future. If anything, the possibilities for further substitution of capital are likely to expand with the advent of self-driving vehicles, self-service technology in retail, automated fast food preparation, and so on.” What this means is that “at some point, policymakers will have to grapple with the implications of these changes for living standards of the middle class.”

Why wait? Finance Minister Bill Morneau has failed to provide a serious analytical framework for addressing the middle-class challenge. We need a new version of the Economic Council of Canada (the former Economic Council was abolished by prime minister Brian Mulroney after it published reports he didn’t like) as an arm’s-length and independent body of experts to research and publish future-looking studies to help policymakers and the public better understand and analyze the challenges we face. If we really want to boost the middle class we need better knowledge and ideas than we have today.

David Crane can be reached at crane@interlog.com.

                  The Hill Times 

Politics This Morning

Get the latest news from The Hill Times

Politics This Morning


Your email has been added. An email has been sent to your address, please click the link inside of it to confirm your subscription.

Feds’ policing reforms should respect self-governance of Indigenous people, say experts, Parliamentarians, in wake of deadly, violent run-ins with police

News|By Palak Mangat
'Our relationship with police has been one of violence, from the colonial nature of everything that has happened in Canada,' says Judith Sayers, president of the Nuu-chah-nulth Tribal Council in Port Alberni, B.C.

Lack of privacy oversight could hurt buy-in for COVID contact-tracing app, say critics

'I get we're in a pandemic, and I'm very supportive of using the technology, but until I know that it respects the basic rights and has the highest standards, I can't see that it's going to work,' said MP Charlie Angus.

‘I felt silenced’: voices missing from Upper Chamber’s systemic racism debate, say some Senators, highlighting need for hybrid model

Senator Mobina Jaffer is among those who say the in-person-only approach to spring Senate sittings limited participation and worries it will remain in place when Parliament returns in September.

Mounting deaths stemming from police wellness checks a ‘wake-up call,’ says Senator

‘We need to address poverty and support community programs to prevent many of the situations that police are being asked to handle with guns and handcuffs,' says NDP critic Don Davies.

New NAFTA comes into force after months of testy renegotiations, but ‘disruptions’ will need to be addressed

News|By Neil Moss
'We all have to expect that there's going to be some bumps over the next six months,' said Ohio-based trade lawyer Daniel Ujczo.

Backroom, Capitol Hill lobbying key to fighting possible return of tariffs, says MP Wayne Easter

News|By Neil Moss
'At least at this stage, it's better to work the backrooms, work the players that have some influence with the White House, and try to ensure that such a threat doesn't become a reality,' says Canada-U.S. group co-chair.

‘Just not the same’: Parliamentarians plan Canada Day festivities around the COVID-19 pandemic

Feature|By Palak Mangat
'We do not celebrate the existence of this country in the same way other people do, because we think that the existence of this country came at a price to our ancestors and to us,' says Senator Murray Sinclair.

Transformative global pandemic could bring positive changes to society, but will require ‘an incredible amount of political will,’ say politicos, pollsters

News|By Abbas Rana
The deeper the impacts of COVID-19, the more likely that major changes will occur in our society, says EKOS president Frank Graves.

MacKay’s victory could be a ‘threat to the party unity,’ says Conservative MP Kusie

News|By Abbas Rana
'Peter MacKay has a proven track record of uniting Conservatives, and that's precisely what he's doing in the leadership campaign. And that's what he'll do if he's elected as leader,' says Conservative MP Michael Cooper.
Your group subscription includes premium access to Politics This Morning briefing.