Home Page News Opinion Foreign Policy Politics Policy Legislation Lobbying Hill Life & People Hill Climbers Heard On The Hill Calendar Archives Classifieds
Hill Times Events Hill Times Books Hill Times Careers The Wire Report The Lobby Monitor Parliament Now
Subscribe Free Trial Reuse & Permissions Advertising
Log In

Brazeau challenges Trudeau to ‘live up to his narrative about reconciliation’ by eliminating sex-based inequities in Indian Act

By Senator Patrick Brazeau      

In the wake of the prime minister's controversial comments about him to Rolling Stone magazine, Independent Senator Patrick Brazeau is urging Justin Trudeau to support legislation eliminating differences in Indigenous registration based on sex, regardless of birth year.

Independent Senator Patrick Brazeau, pictured in this file photo on the Hill, is challenging Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to move past his controversial Rolling Stone comments about him and support an effort by the Senate to eliminate sex-based discrepancies under the Indian Act for all Indigenous peoples. The Hill Times photograph by Jake Wright
Share a story
The story link will be added automatically.

You may have heard about some controversial remarks made by the prime minister about me in Rolling Stone magazine. In the article he referred to me as “Indigenous” which is true, and “scrappy,” which, if ever true, is becoming less so with advancing years. The most important outcome of our boxing match is that, together, we raised a lot of money for cancer research.

So, I hold no ill will towards the prime minister about those Rolling Stone comments and I would challenge him to live up to his narrative about reconciliation.

Sometimes you hear people saying that the relationship between First Nations and mainstream Canadians will take “generations” to fix. You often hear that there are no easy solutions. That is false and leads to paralysis and stonewalling.

Take a look at Bill S-3—An Act to amend the Indian Act. This bill aims to remove the sex-based inequalities from the Indian Act. The bill would give children born to women the same rights to their heritage as children with Indigenous fathers from 1951 onward.

An important amendment has been proposed that would eliminate the sex-based inequities in registration in their entirety, not limiting the equality only to the children born to women since 1951.

The prime minister likes to talk about principles and equality. That is part of his narrative. It is his “right story to tell.” But is this all talk and no action?

The refusal to remove all the sexism as requested in the amendment affects two of my children directly. I have been told that, due to the delay in the passage of the bill, my son cannot expect to be granted his status for one to two years. My youngest daughter would never receive her status. My family’s story is only one of the many who are directly and deeply affected by the prime minister’s action—or inaction —on this file.

For First Nations people, our status is primary. Just as a mainstream Canadians cherish their passport or citizenship papers, we cherish our status. It is a part of who we are. Our status connects us to our communities. And as the demographics of Canada change over the years, our status is something that keeps us strongly connected to who we are.

I challenge to prime minister to move on from his Rolling Stone comments and to turn his attention back to S-3, back to his stated beliefs in fairness and justice. I ask him to be a champion for equality rather than just talking about being one.


The Hill Times

More in News

Refugee advocates dispute Canada facing ‘crisis’ over arrival of claimants from U.S. border, NDP says ‘Conservatives misrepresent issue’

Politicians and some journalists have been loose with the words 'illegal' and 'crisis,' which doesn't apply to Canada's situation, says Alex Neve of Amnesty International Canada.

Amid strained relations with U.S., Ontario, Trudeau debuts bigger cabinet with fresh faces, new posts

Five MPs were sworn in as new ministers, expanding the front bench to 35 from 30, while 11 existing cabinet members were shuffled to new posts or had their titles and responsibilities altered. No one was dropped.

Some politicos question Grégoire Trudeau’s involvement in government activities, others say she deserves more credit for her work

News|By Emily Haws
Sophie Grégoire Trudeau has been given an honorary title by Parks Canada and appeared at a 2018 post-budget announcement with Labour Minister Patty Hajdu, among other activities.

NPR, Politico latest U.S. news outlets expanding northward, shaking up Canadian media environment

News|By Emily Haws
Hill reporters say it's not a direct threat to them, but some worry about how a shift in news consumption to U.S. outlets could eat away at Canadian outlets' revenues.

Centre Block occupants prepare for summer clear-out

Though plans are still not concrete, roughly 20 Liberal MPs, nine Conservative MPs, five NDP MPs, 10 Senators, and Senate administration staff will be moving this summer.

High-level bureaucrat’s public sector exit prompts shuffle among Phoenix fixers

News|By Emily Haws
Marc Lemieux has taken over from assistant deputy minister Danielle May-Cuconato, who was in charge of the project management office behind the Phoenix fix.

PMO mum over whether Trudeau raised concerns over ‘rising tide’ of anti-Semitism with the Latvian PM

News|By Neil Moss
The feds can be more forthright to condemn Nazi glorification and anti-Semitism in Europe, says a leading Jewish Canadian advocacy group.

House committee votes to examine feds’ response to migrant issue, calls in three ministers to testify

News|By Jolson Lim
At a time of increased tension between the federal and Ontario governments over who should cough up money for them, the committee voted unanimously to study the federal response to and impact of migrant crossings on some cities and provinces.

Trudeau’s handling of groping allegation has ‘terribly set back’ progress on women’s issues, puts him in tricky situation too, say political players

'I've had an inbox full of messages from victims saying, 'What do I do now? Because I'm really worried that the tide is turning back,' says Kathleen Finlay, CEO of the Centre for Patient Protection.