Sunday, Feb. 12, 2012
START A FREE TRIAL | SUBSCRIBE | LOG IN
Sign up for the free daily email

Email
Print

The use, misuse, and abuse of prorogation

No Prime Minister has so abused the power to prorogue. Harper's former chief of staff Tom Flanagan understood the obvious: the purpose of prorogation was to terminate Parliament's probing of the Afghan detainee issue.

TORONTO—Defending the prorogation of Parliament, Stephen Harper asserted it is a "fairly standard procedure"; it had occurred 104 times since Confederation. Actually, it has occurred 120 times, tallying his three prorogations since 2007. This does not buttress the point that Harper's prorogations are "routine" (as a Conservative email alleges) because, with rare exception, prorogation occurs as described in Bourinot's Parliamentary Procedure and Practice: "As soon as the business of the two Houses is concluded, or so nearly completed that there can be no doubt as to the time of prorogation...." Eugene Forsey said the same: "When both Houses have finished a session's business, Parliament is 'prorogued' till the next session." Only then is prorogation "routine."

To View the rest of this article, please choose one of the following

If you are already a subscriber

Subscribe to The Hill Times

Subscribe to the print and electronic editions and get instant access to The Hill Times online.


Quick Purchase

Purchase this weeks' edition of The Hill Times in electronic format (PDF) for $4.00


Sign Up for a free trial

For instant access to the website.



Email
Print

The use, misuse, and abuse of prorogation

No Prime Minister has so abused the power to prorogue. Harper's former chief of staff Tom Flanagan understood the obvious: the purpose of prorogation was to terminate Parliament's probing of the Afghan detainee issue.

TORONTO—Defending the prorogation of Parliament, Stephen Harper asserted it is a "fairly standard procedure"; it had occurred 104 times since Confederation. Actually, it has occurred 120 times, tallying his three prorogations since 2007. This does not buttress the point that Harper's prorogations are "routine" (as a Conservative email alleges) because, with rare exception, prorogation occurs as described in Bourinot's Parliamentary Procedure and Practice: "As soon as the business of the two Houses is concluded, or so nearly completed that there can be no doubt as to the time of prorogation...." Eugene Forsey said the same: "When both Houses have finished a session's business, Parliament is 'prorogued' till the next session." Only then is prorogation "routine."

  

Parliamentary Calendar
Sunday, February 12, 2012
HILL LIFE & PEOPLE SLIDESHOWS
Fare thee well, Jane Feb. 2, 2012

The Hill Times Photograph by Jake Wright
The Globe and Mail's Jane Taber and CBC's Julie Van Dusen
The Hill Times Photograph by Jake Wright
The NDP's Brad Lavigne and Anne McGrath
The Hill Times Photograph by Jake Wright
NDP MP Megan Leslie and CTV's Don Martin
The Hill Times Photograph by Jake Wright
The Globe's Shawn McCarthy
The Hill Times Photograph by Jake Wright
iPolitics' Matthew Rowe and Liberal MP Rodger Cuzner
The Hill Times Photograph by Jake Wright
The NDP's Gaby Senay and the Toronto Star's Joanna Smith
The Hill Times Photograph by Jake Wright
Ensight's Jacquie LaRocque
The Hill Times Photograph by Jake Wright
The crowd at Metropolitain
The Hill Times Photograph by Jake Wright
Citizenship and Immigration Minister Jason Kenney
The Hill Times Photograph by Jake Wright
Liberal MP Geoff Regan
The Hill Times Photograph by Jake Wright
Green Party Leader Elizabeth May and freelance reporter Richard Cleroux
The Hill Times Photograph by Jake Wright
CTV's Craig Oliver, Global's Tom Clark and CTV's Kevin Newman
The Hill Times Photograph by Jake Wright
Global's Kevin Newman
The Hill Times Photograph by Jake Wright
Liberal Interim Leader Bob Rae
The Hill Times Photograph by Jake Wright
Richard Cleroux, CPAC's Peter Van Dusen and the Globe's Jane Taber
The Hill Times Photograph by Jake Wright
Postmedia's Stephen Maher

MICHAEL DE ADDER'S TAKE